But some in her top team offered support, taking to Twitter to post an infographic with a quotation from the media briefing, where she said: “We will deliver the strong and sustained growth that can transform the prosperity of our country for generations to come.”
Simon Clarke, the chief secretary to the Treasury, raised eyebrows when he simply tweeted: “The prime minister has my support.”
Therese Coffey, Ranil Jayawardena and Jake Berry followed.
The PM is right to act now to ensure our country’s economic stability – key for families and businesses – and reassure the markets of our fiscal discipline, especially in light of the worsening global economic conditions with Putin’s illegal invasion of Ukraine. https://t.co/LChPGrnhOR
The Prime Minister has acted in the national interest to reassure the markets of our fiscal discipline and provide economic stability. pic.twitter.com/Mf8PgDniX0
But Tom Tugendhat, minister of state for security who attends cabinet, resisted adding a message of support to the graphic – while Kemi Bandenoch resisted adding the graphic to her message of support.
The international trade secretary, who came fourth in the Conservative party leadership contest earlier this year, wrote: “To say it’s been a difficult day would be an understatement. We knew the scale of the challenge this autumn given multiple global headwinds would be unprecedented. Our Prime Minister is working flat out to get the country through these turbulent times. She has my full support.”
But while the pound bounces around the bottom and mortgage rates surge, the slither of a silver lining is the quality of the content on Twitter.
On Friday, the catastrophic mini-budget struck again as Liz Truss sacked her chancellor Kwasi Kwarteng as she abandoned plans to freeze corporation tax.
Many political reporters, speaking to Tory MPs, suggested the media briefing – eight minutes, just four questions – made things worse. You can see why they might say that.
FUN FACT: The song ‘American Pie’ is 8 minutes and 42 seconds long. Longer than PM Liz Truss’s press conference.
And there was a reminder not to stand too close to either of the top two in government …
… especially if they are indulging in a spot of campanology.
Advertisement
And Britain appeared to be living up to its ‘Normal Island’ nickname.
Back in his constituency, Truss critic Michael Gove was getting on with business.
No, there was absolutely no trolling going on as the former cabinet minister referred to “trip hazards”, “strong leadership”, “funding pressures” and “recruitment and retention”.
Good to talk to Surrey Heath headteachers today – providing strong leadership for the next generation. We discussed funding pressures, support for the vulnerable and recruitment and retention. pic.twitter.com/RKfIB5t7Qd
This morning, I was with Cllr Edward Hawkins at Heather Ridge Arcade. It was good to see work being done on trip hazards, and the job will be completed early next month. Edward also updated me on progress on the Ravenscote crossing campaign – all should be fixed by mid November pic.twitter.com/Zm8LL0Ghko
The fever that has taken over the Tory party didn’t start with Liz Truss. Trickle down economics has been the guiding philosophy for 12 years. It has failed.
Liz Truss has been savaged by Tory MPs after a disastrous meeting with her backbenchers.
In a bid to win over her mutinous MPs, Truss on Wednesday evening addressed the Tory backbench 1922 Committee, including high-profile critics Michael Gove and Grant Shapps.
But one MP described her performance as “crap” while another told HuffPost UK she was “wooden”.
The showdown in Commitee Room 14 of the House of Commons came as the economic chaos sparked by Kwasi Kwarteng’s mini-budget continued.
Advertisement
Truss told the MPs present that the government’s energy price guarantee would protect households and businesses from soaring bills this winter.
She called on her colleagues to “highlight the devastation that would have been caused to small business had we not acted”.
But her attempts to win over her own MPs failed, with one telling HuffPost UK that almost all of the questions she was asked were critical of the government.
One said: “She was crap and the atmosphere was pretty flat in the room. Even the whips couldn’t be bothered getting people to ask supportive questions.”
Advertisement
One backbencher said her remaining supporters were “libertarian Jihadists who are wrecking the party”.
Former minister Robert Halfon, the Tory MP for Harlow, told Truss she had “trashed blue collar conservatism” by weakening the government’s commitment to affordable housing and lifting the cap on bankers’ bonuses.
Another MP said: “I would say it was worse than anything Theresa May ever faced when she was leader.
“What was really noticeable was the failure of the whips to organise a Praetorian guard of supporters around her. There was only one mildly supportive question and the rest were hostile.
“There was clapping on tables when the government’s policies were criticised and groans when the PM was giving an answer on interest rates and saying they were going up around the world. Try telling that to voters who are seeing their mortgages go up.”
The MP added: “She was wooden, cardboard, lacking in empathy. It’s very bleak.
“It felt very sombre and the mood was a bit like ’what’s going to happen next to bring this to a conclusion?”
Advertisement
The meeting capped another difficult day for the prime minister after she endured a tough prime minister’s questions in which she stunned MPs by declaring she would not impose any spending cuts to pay for the government’s tax giveaways.
The governor of the Bank of England made clear its emergency support programme for the county’s fragile bond market will end on Friday – sparking another sell-off of the pound.
Andrew Bailey warned pension fund managers “you’ve got three days left” to balance the books as the central banker made clear efforts to shore up the financial markets had to be temporary.
Advertisement
It’s almost two weeks since the Bank launched a massive programme to help pension funds cope with a slump in bond prices triggered by the announcement of unfunded tax cuts by the new Liz Truss government.
Earlier on Tuesday, it made a fresh attempt to soothe market chaos, enacting another round of emergency bond-buying after a renewed bout of market turbulence.
Investors have been selling-off government bonds – also known as gilts – as investor concerns about the state of the British economy has failed to subside.
Following the announcement by the governor, the pound plunged against the dollar to below $1.10.
Spooked by the biggest raft of tax cuts for half a century, the pound fell to its lowest point ever against the dollar following the mini-budget – dropping to just over $1.03 – but has rebounded since in no small part thanks to the Bank’s efforts.
Advertisement
Gosh Just look at what happened to the pound when @bankofengland Governor Andrew Bailey told investors its emergency support will definitely end on Friday. “You’ve got three days left now,” he said. “You’ve got to get this done.” pic.twitter.com/ij9verfBBW
At an event organised by the Institute of International Finance in Washington on Tuesday, Bailey said: “We have announced that we will be out by the end of this week. We think the rebalancing must be done.
“And my message to the funds involved and all the firms involved managing those funds: You’ve got three days left now. You’ve got to get this done.”
Earlier on Tuesday, the Pensions and Lifetime Savings Association, an industry body, urged the BoE to extend the bond-buying programme until October 31 “and possibly beyond”.
Advertisement
Why has the Bank stepped in with more emergency action?
On Tuesday, the Bank said it needed to broaden the emergency programme to buy UK government bonds to calm markets as it warned over a “material risk to UK financial stability”.
Advertisement
It came after a further sell-off in the gilt market, which saw the yields on long-dated government bonds rise back up close to levels seen in the immediate aftermath of the mini-budget.
What are gilts and gilt yields?
UK government bonds are a way for the government to raise money.
A gilt is essentially an IOU that the Treasury writes to its lenders, promising to pay the money back, plus interest, within a time frame, for example over two, 10 or 30 years.
The yield on a gilt is the amount of money an investor receives for owning the debt and is represented as a percentage of its price. When a bond price falls, its yield rises.
Yields rise when investors are less willing to own the debt, meaning they will pay a lower price for the bonds.
Why are bond yields rising?
Concerns over the chancellor’s plans for unfunded tax cuts sent gilt yields soaring as markets fretted over the Government’s economic policies.
Advertisement
At one stage, the yield on 30-year gilts hit levels not seen since 2002 in the chaos that followed the mini-budget statement, while the pound also plunged to record lows against the US dollar.
What do gilt prices have to do with pension funds?
Pension funds invest huge amounts of money in gilts, which are seen as safe investments in usual times.
In order to protect themselves against sharp rises in government borrowing costs, funds have been investing in products that act as a kind of insurance – so-called liability driven investment (LDI) funds.
But due to the sudden rise in government borrowing costs after the mini-budget, investment banks called on these LDIs to put up assets or cash as securities for loans, which in turn called on pension funds, forcing them into a fire sale of gilts, driving prices still lower and yields higher and creating a downward spiral.
How bad is the latest crisis in financial markets?
The Bank warned last week that it had been been forced to step in to avoid market meltdown, when some pension funds were left close to collapse and there was a risk of a knock-on impact elsewhere in the financial system.
Advertisement
Its measures initially eased pressure on gilt yields, but they spiked higher again and there are signs the woes may be spreading elsewhere, to index-linked gilts, as well as corporate bonds and even in niche debt markets in the US.
Will my pension be affected?
Experts say the gilt rout, which is largely affecting final salary and defined benefit pensions schemes, will not impact policyholders.
The Pensions and Lifetime Savings Association (PLSA) said: “Although there has been a great deal of commentary over the last few weeks, members of defined benefit pension schemes should be reassured that their pension benefits are safe; scheme funding is strong and, despite the operational challenges, funding will have been strengthened further by rising yields.”
Why are mortgage rates rising?
Higher gilt yields and the prospect of rising interest rates as the Bank looks to cool rampant inflation have a significant impact on mortgage lenders.
Rates on two and five fixed year deals have gone past 6% for the first time in many years due to the market turmoil, while lenders have also been pulling hundreds of products.
Advertisement
Will the latest action be enough?
There are concerns that when the Bank’s programme comes to a close on October 14, there will be a further sell-off of gilts, leaving pension funds in chaos once more.
The PLSA has called for the bond-buying programme to be extended to the chancellor’s next fiscal statement on October 31 or even beyond, suggesting there may yet be further intervention from the Bank.
A photographer who was ejected from the Conservative Party conference despite having a press pass has criticised security for “manhandling” him.
Staff photojournalist at European Pressphoto Agency (EPA), Tolga Akmen, said he had taken photos of Liz Truss crossing the bridge to get to the International Convention Centre in Birmingham, before moving towards the hall where the Prime Minister was set to give her speech.
Advertisement
But video on social media shows Akmen, 31, then being forcibly moved by two men while he states “I’m not being aggressive” and “I’m a member of the media”.
The photographer told the PA news agency afterwards: “There was no need for manhandling. We could have talked about it. I didn’t try to get in where I wasn’t allowed to.
“I don’t see anyone else being told off and I do not know why they picked on me.
“I happen to be someone who argued back, and they don’t (take) kindly to that. We should have access and are accredited media. I showed them my press card.
Advertisement
“I have never had anything like this happen in my life. Weird behaviour, really strange.”
Akmen said he showed his press pass to security and tried to enter via the closest entrance, but was refused access and was given no alternative points from which to enter.
Akmen said he and colleagues then walked towards another entrance before he heard a security guard radioing his description, saying he had been acting “aggressively and needed to be stopped”.
That same guard, he claims, followed him then “singled him out” from the other journalists and “started pushing and dragging” him away with other security.
The award-winning photographer said he had been briefed by Conservative Party press officers regarding where media were allowed access during the conference in Birmingham.
A video showing him being taken away was posted on social media by podcast producer Dino Sofos.
In it, a man tells Akmen he was being “aggressive”.
Akmen responds: “I’m a member of the media. Can you stop this please? What are you doing? I didn’t do anything … I promise you, I didn’t do anything.”
Advertisement
A man can be heard saying: “I’d go with him now, otherwise the police will get involved, but go now and we’ll try and sort it out.”
Akmen said after the footage was taken he was “thrown out” in the rain without his equipment and jacket, which was later recovered by security.
He said EPA had raised the matter with the Conservative Party.
A Conservative Party spokesman said: “We are aware there was an incident earlier today where a photographer was removed by venue security staff.
“We believe there may have been a misunderstanding and have been in contact with the photographer.”
Akmen confirmed Conservative Campaign Headquarters had been in touch to apologise, adding that he was waiting for a formal apology to be sent.
PA has contacted the International Convention Centre for comment.
In her keynote conference speech, the prime minister railed against those she accused of trying to hold back her pro-growth agenda, including Labour, “militant” unions, “Brexit deniers”, Extinction Rebellion and “some of the people we had in the hall earlier” – a reference to the protesters who disrupted her address.
It’s clearly an attack line her senior team are rallying around, as Cabinet minister Nadhim Zahawi was among those to tweet out the slogan.
It’s worth printing the diatribe in full to get a better idea of who she thinks they are and what they do:
“I will not allow the anti-growth coalition to hold us back.
“Labour, the Lib Dems, the SNP, the militant unions, the vested interests dressed up as think tanks, the talking heads, the Brexit deniers, Extinction Rebellion and some of the people we had in the hall earlier.
“The fact is they prefer protesting to doing. They prefer talking on Twitter to taking tough decisions.
“They taxi from north London townhouses to the BBC studio to dismiss anyone challenging the status quo.
“From broadcast to podcast, they peddle the same old answers.
“It’s always more taxes, more regulation and more meddling.
“Wrong, wrong, wrong.”
It seems to be a wide-ranging term that could anyone you would file under “the establishment” or anything vaguely “woke”.
Given the elasticity of the phrase, questions were asked about whether healthy food campaigner Jamie Oliver was also part of the rabble putting the brakes on Truss and her policies.
In her speech, the PM signalled the scrapping of the planned ban on junk food multi-buy deals as she declared she is “not interested in how many two-for-one offers you buy at the supermarket”.
Downing Street later did not rule out that the anti-growth coalition included the celebrity chef, who supports the ban.
The prime minister’s press secretary suggested there could be a scrapping of the planned ban of buy one, get one free offers, saying: “You’ll have to wait for announcements on that.”
When asked if Oliver is part of the anti-growth coalition, he responded: “I’m not going to name individuals.”
The speech has prompted people on Twitter to suggest a whole range of members of the coalition, including bats, David Attenborough and Conservative councils.
He first hit out at the “gutter press” for its negative portrayal of the event, which was marred by a u-turn on scrapping the 45p top rate of tax and civil war within the Tory party.
He then praised Truss for a “pretty good” address, and how she “gets better and better every time I see her”.
Anderson added: “I think we’ve made the right decision in the end to vote for her.”
Asked whether Truss did enough to win over any floating voters in his constituency, Anderson said he “would hope so” but acknowledged that “the red wall is a red wall for a reason”.
He went on: “We had Brexit, we had Boris, we had Corbyn three years ago and now we’ve got Theresa May it’s a different ball game altogether.”
Ashfield MP Lee Anderson tells the ‘gutter press’: “We had Brexit, we had Boris, we had Corbyn. Now we’ve got Theresa May it’s a different ball game altogether…” pic.twitter.com/69fv28UHIh
When interviewer Harry Horton of ITV remind him that the prime minister was in fact now Truss, Anderson conceded: “My mistake, it’s been a long few days.”
Earlier in the week, Anderson insisted the government’s “change of direction” on scrapping the 45p tax rate wasn’t a “u-turn”.
A Conservative MP has hit out at the “comedic figures masquerading as government ministers” as Tory anger over Kwasi Kwarteng’s mini-budget continued despite an astonishing U-turn on income tax cuts for the highest earners.
Johnny Mercer, who was last month removed as veterans affairs minister by new prime minister Liz Truss, said “they can do whatever they like with the whip” as he warned he would be speaking out in the Commons about the controversial package.
Advertisement
Tory MPs who vote against the prime minister’s tax measures have been warned they will be kicked out of the parliamentary party – known as losing the whip.
In a Facebook post, the Plymouth MP wrote: “You know I will not accept budgets like the ones we saw last week. It is hard watching these rather comedic figures masquerading as government ministers sprawling around in the media.
“Last week my friend had to close his coffee shop. Another had his mortgage pulled. It is deeply unfunny for normal people, and I will waste no time in letting them know in the Commons at the first opportunity.
“I will not support anything that doesn’t help the brilliant people of Plymouth through intensely difficult times – they can do whatever they like with the whip.”
Advertisement
When Mercer was fired, his wife, Felicity Cornelius-Mercer, took to Twitter to call Truss an “imbecile” as she said the Cabinet system “stinks” and “treats people appallingly”.
The MP’s comments came on the same day as Kwarteng abandoned plans to scrap the 45% rate for earnings over £150,000 to stave off a Tory revolt.
Former Cabinet minister Michael Gove suggested he could now support the package and fellow potential rebel Grant Shapps welcoming the U-turn.
But HuffPost UK has reported that many angry Conservative MPs now want the government to stick by Boris Johnson’s promise to raise benefits by the rate of inflation — something Truss and Kwarteng have so far failed to do as they draw up plans to slash public spending.
Advertisement
One MP said: “Thank the lord for the 45p U-turn, but that’s after billions lost from shares, £65 billion spent by the Bank of England to prop up pension funds, asking MPs to defend the indefensible and threatening MPs with losing the party whip if they vote against.
“What they have to do now is maintain the real term increases in benefits and spending for essential public services. If not, that’s when people will speak out again.”
At the Tory party conference in Birmingham, the chancellor joked about his humiliating 45p tax rate U-turn.
“What a day,” he told the Tory conference as he admitted there had been “a little turbulence” since his mini-budget, a reference to the economic chaos caused by his unfunded tax cuts.
Unease is mounting among Tory backbenchers as the Labour Party has mounted a 30-point poll lead in at least two surveys in the last week, enough for a landslide election victory.
Advertisement
Johnson loyalist Nadine Dorries has called for an early election as she accused Truss of trashing the former PM’s legacy.
The former culture secretary said there is “widespread dismay at the fact that three years of work has effectively been put on hold”.
Kwasi Kwarteng will double down on his plan for unfunded tax cuts despite the economic chaos and a mounting Tory rebellion.
The chancellor will tell the Conservative conference in Birmingham the government must “stay the course”.
Advertisement
And he will say: “I am confident our plan is the right one.”
Kwarteng’s comments risk further inflaming the Tory civil war, with Michael Gove among the big-hitters urging the government to change course.
The former cabinet minister said he was “profoundly” concerned by the mini-budget, which saw the chancellor unveil plans to slash taxes for the highest earners and end the cap on bankers’ bonuses.
Gove also suggested that he would join other Tory rebels in voting against the plans when they come before parliament – despite party chairman Jake Berry warning that any MP who does so will lose the whip.
In a sign of the mounting anger, 13 Tory MPs have now gone public to voice their opposition to the decision to axe the 45p tax rate paid by those earning more than £150,000.
Advertisement
They include former chief whip Julian Smith, who said: “We cannot clap for carers one month and cut tax for millionaires months later.”
The first job of an MP is to act in the interest of their constituents & in the national interest. We cannot clap for carers one month & cut tax for millionaires months later. https://t.co/iKtnOxm1jB
But in his keynote address to the party faithful in Birmingham today, Kwarteng will insist he had no choice but to take radical action to grow the UK economy, and will not back down.
He will say: “We must face up to the facts that for too long our economy has not grown enough.
“The path ahead of us was one of slow, managed decline, and I refuse to accept that it is somehow Britain’s destiny to fall into middle income status, or that the tax burden reaching a 70-year-high is somehow inevitable – it isn’t, and shouldn’t be.
Advertisement
“We needed a new approach, focused on raising economic growth.That is the only real way to deliver higher wages, more jobs, and crucially, revenue to fund our precious public servicee and it is the only way to achieve long-term fiscal sustainability.
“We must stay the course. I am confident our plan is the right one.”
The chancellor will add: “With energy bills skyrocketing.A 70 year high tax burden.Slowing long-term growth rates. Painfully slow infrastructure delivery.
“Should we really have just accepted that fate? Think about the cost to livelihoods and the impact on our communities.
“What Britain needs is economic growth.And a government wholly committed to economic growth.
“That is why we will forge a new economic deal for Britain backed by an iron-clad commitment to fiscal discipline.”
The chancellor’s speech will be closely watched by the money markets for details on precisely how the government plans to balance the books.
The language of economics and the financial system can be confusing for those not steeped in the world of pensions, gilts and bear markets.
But there’s been a lot of around, as the Conservative Party’s mini-budget spooked the markets, causing a collapse in the pound and a surge in the UK’s borrowing costs. Here’s an explanation to some of the phrases and ideas being bandied around.
Advertisement
Why is ‘supply-side economics’ being mentioned?
The economic theory is highly fashionable having been fully embraced by the UK’s new prime minister, Liz Truss and her chancellor, Kwasi Kwarteng, in their controversial “fiscal event”.
The theory holds that the supply of goods and services within the economy is the main driver of growth. Put bluntly, the idea is to give wealthy individuals or large corporations tax cuts, which in turn creates jobs and later increases the number of people paying taxes and boosts the amount of money collected by the Treasury. The prime minister’s approach has been dubbed “Trussonomics”, and supporters talk a lot about baking a bigger economic “pie” that everyone can share.
The theory was particularly popular in right-wing circles in the 1980s. In common with US president Ronald Reagan, UK prime minister Margaret Thatcher experimented in this kind of low-tax economics, the results of which have been disputed ever since.
Advertisement
The phrase “trickle-down” economics – the benefits generated at the top trickling down to everyone – has become synonymous with the idea.
When talking about supply-side economics, commentators will invariably refer to the Laffer Curve – a graph showing the relationship between tax rates and the amount of tax revenue collected by governments. It’s named after Arthur Laffer, a member of Reagan’s economic policy advisory board, who also advised Thatcher, earning him the nickname the “father” of supply-side economics.
When do we know we’re in a recession?
A technical recession is defined by two successive quarters of falling economic output – measured by gross domestic product (GDP), which attempts to summarise all the activity of companies, governments and individuals in an economy in a single figure.
Some people argue the term “recession” is an unreliable indicator because people could be suffering all the effects of an economic downturn, such as long-term unemployment, but the data might not officially say as much.
Kwarteng has admitted the UK is “technically” in a recession, even if the official figures are yet to confirm it.
Advertisement
In 2020, the Office for National Statistics (ONS) officially declared the UK in recession – the steepest on record – after the economy plunged by 19.6% between April and June due to the coronavirus lockdown.
It followed a 2.2% contraction in the previous three months – marking the first recession since the 2008 global financial crisis, when the UK fell into a year-long recession.
What is inflation?
At its heart, inflation is the measure of how quickly the cost of goods and services is growing. It is an average across many categories, so if food prices rise, that could still be offset by drops in, say, the price of petrol.
In the UK, the ONS is tasked with estimating the inflation rate.
It has a basket of goods and services that it tracks. It might be helpful to think of this as a massive shopping basket with what the ONS thinks that people in the UK buy. It includes around 730 items, anything from dating agency fees to condoms, wild bird seed to petrol, and crumpets to pet food.
What is in the basket changes every year – with some additions and some removals – because what people buy changes. For 2022 antibacterial surface wipes were added, along with meat-free sausages and other items.
Advertisement
What’s the Bank of England’s role?
Owned by but independent from the UK government, the Bank of England is tasked with keeping inflation under control, targeting 2% a year.
But in recent months inflation has started to run away. It hit 9.9% in August and, despite government action to freeze energy bills, is still expected to strike a new 40-year-high “just below 11%”, the central bank has said.
The Bank of England also has a wider remit to ensure the health of the economy. Many will remember the economy-boosting stimulus in the form of quantitative easing – often referred to as printing money – being deployed during the 2008 financial crisis.
How do interest rates fit in?
An interest rate is a measure that tells you how high the cost of borrowing money is, or how high the rewards are for saving.
Advertisement
The Bank of England’s “base rate” – the interest rate at which banks borrow from the central bank, which has billions of pounds in assets at its disposal – has a knock-on effect on the interest rates offered on the high-street for mortgages and savings.
Raising and lowering interest rates is the blunt instrument at the Bank’s disposal to control the economy. Hiking the base rate increases the cost of borrowing, making both credit and investment more expensive. The idea is to put the brakes on the economy and curb soaring inflation. Bringing rates down is an attempt to have the opposite effect – stimulate growth by making borrowing cheaper, and in turn, encourage investment.
Before the mini-budget, the Bank raised the base rate by 0.5 percentage points – the seventh hike since December – in a bid to keep inflation under control. Now some analysts are predicting the base rate, currently standing at 2.25%, will have to rise to as high as 6% next year.
What about bonds and yields?
The Bank of England has also intervened to try to bring surging yields in government bonds – known as gilts – under control as they spiralled higher, sending UK public borrowing costs soaring.
Advertisement
It said it would buy bonds “on whatever scale is necessary”. The Bank stepped in to calm markets after some types of pension funds were at risk of collapse.
Bonds are loans that investors make to a bond issuer and can be issued by companies or governments to raise money.
The yield on a bond is the amount of money an investor receives for owning the debt and is represented as a percentage of its price. When a bond price falls, its yield rises.
Yields fall when investors are less willing to own the debt, meaning they will pay a lower price for the bonds.
Alarm bells were ringing when yields on 10-year UK government bonds rose above 4%, the highest since the 2008 financial crisis, and more than triple the 1.3% rate at the start of the year.
Advertisement
The higher yield reflected fears investors had in the state of the UK economy, and again impacts how much interest banks charge for various types of loans, most notably mortgages.